| Honour | Year(s) | |
|---|---|---|
| West of Scotland Super League Premier Division | Winners | – |
| Runners-up | – | |
| West of Scotland Super League First Division | Winners | 2013–2014 |
| Runners-up | 2002–03 | |
| Ayrshire District League | Winners | – |
| Runners-up | 2012–13 | |
| Ayrshire Second Division | Winners | 1996–97, 2000–01 |
| Runners-up | – | |
| Scottish Junior Cup | Winners | – |
| Runners-up | – | |
| West of Scotland Cup | Winners | 2004–05, 2025-26 |
| Runners-up | 2013–14, 2011–12 | |
| Ayrshire Cup | Winners | 2013–14 |
| Runners-up | – | |
| Ayrshire League Cup | Winners | – |
| Runners-up | – | |
| Ayrshire Super Cup | Winners | 2000–01 |
| Runners-up | – | |
| South Ayrshire Cup | Winners | 1996–97, 1998–99, 1999–00, 2000–01, 2002–03, 2003–04 |
| Runners-up | – | |
| Ayrshire District Cup | Winners | 1996–97 |
| Runners-up | – | |
| Kyle & Carrick Cup | Winners | 1994–95 |
| Runners-up | – | |
| Ayrshire Consolation Cup | Winners | 1904–05,1923–24 |
| Runners-up | – | |
| Land O’Burns Cup | Winners | 1954 |
| Runners-up | – | |
| Gold Watch Competition | Winners | 1936 |
| Runners-up | – | |
| Ayrshire Intermediate Cup | Winners | 1929 |
| Runners-up | – | |
| Kilmarnock & District League | Winners | 1921 |
| Runners-up | – | |
| Irvine Herald Cup | Winners | 1895 |
| Runners-up | – | |